Weighty Issues

My weight graph since I started weight watchers in September 2007

How much should I weigh to be healthy, what weight can I realistically maintain? I have been doing weight watchers for 4 years my starting weight was 20st 7lb. I currently weigh 14st 1lb. May 2010 I was at my lowest at 12st 0.5lb, this was the week before I had my first accident in which duck+front wheel = separated right shoulder and 2 months at home on drugs. Psychologically I hate being in the 13 stone bracket, it feels unlucky. At the moment I feel like I should lose some weight but unsure how much. I have asked the GP and they gave me a really generic, unhelpful response. It is such a complex question, one that I have really struggled to find an answer that I am comfortable with.

At Weight Watchers your goal weight is based upon a healthy BMI. Body Mass Index is a ratio of weight:height and results in a figure, 18-25 is healthy. BMIs fatal flaws is that it doesn’t take into account your body composition, the often cited example is Jonny Wilkinson the muscular rugby player is classed as overweight. Body weight is made up of skeleton, muscle, fat, internal organs and skin. I need to lose fat but losing weight loss could be due to any number of reasons, the weight of my clothes (jeans weigh 2lb+), amount of water that I have drunk, lost muscle or lost fat.

Having lost 6st+ I have been left with excess skin. This isn’t a fact that surprises me, but it does raise the question how much does this excess skin weigh? The excess skin contributes to my weight which in turn increase my BMI but to what extent? I can’t lose the weight of the skin without surgical intervention so I just have to put up with it.

18 months ago I went and got some sports testing done with Garry Palmer last week I went to get re-tested. All my results had gone the in the wrong direction which I knew they would, I just wanted an objective read of where I am right now, not deluding myself with where I was. Amongst other fun tests he performed a caliper skin fold test. It is a slightly more technical version of pinching an inch. Since the last test I have put on 12.3kg (almost 2st) however according to the caliper skin test 5kg of this is muscle, which is a good thing. This test I had 26.4% fat and previously 21.4%, below 18% for a female isn’t good for long-term health. One ratio that is important for cycling is power:weight ratio, my power should increase the fitter I get and if the weight goes down that will increase the ratio too.

If I don’t base it on the scales what should I base it on, feelings? Some people go by feelings; how they feel in the clothes, whether they feel comfortable in their own skin. My issue is that when I was morbidly obese I didn’t feel obese. I knew I needed to lose a bit of weight and gain a bit of fitness but I didn’t feel like I was out of control with what I ate (even though I was).

Having a scientific background means I like numbers and seeing improvement in the figures. I find something comforting in the numbers reinforcing what I believe. Maybe I should just stop looking at numbers and live life.


About marystumbles

These are my thoughts as I stumble through life.
This entry was posted in Weight loss. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Weighty Issues

  1. Darren Hague says:

    Sounds like the best number to optimise is your power:weight ratio, and in the absence of a power meter the best way to get it is to measure your best times when climbing moderately steep hills – Staple Lane is probably a good benchmark. If you lose weight but take longer up the hill then you’re probably losing muscle rather than fat.

  2. sweetopiagirl says:

    Reblogged this on inspiredweightloss.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s